The 2026 PSAL high school football regular season is officially in the books, and what a season it has been across New York City.
From undefeated runs and unexpected losses to disappointing campaigns and programs making major statements, this season has given football fans plenty to discuss. Some teams lived up to the preseason hype, others exceeded expectations, and a few left us wondering what went wrong.
With the playoffs approaching, the biggest question remains: Who is actually built to win a championship?
Let’s break down some of the biggest takeaways from the 2026 PSAL regular season.
Eagle Academy II and Eagle Academy III: Are They the Teams to Beat?
If there is one thing the Eagle Academy programs have established this season, it’s that they belong in the championship conversation.
Eagle Academy II finished with a perfect 10-0 overall record, making a powerful statement in the 4A division. From their impressive out-of-state victories to their dominance against PSAL opponents, the Eagles have looked like one of the most complete teams in New York City.
Their defense has been outstanding, their offense has produced consistently, and they’ve proven they can compete against high-level competition.
But here’s the question: Does an undefeated season automatically make Eagle II the favorite to win it all?
Let’s not forget about Erasmus Hall, a program that has dominated the highest level of PSAL football for years. The Dutchmen are experienced, battle-tested, and know what it takes to win when the games matter most.
Meanwhile, Eagle Academy III has been just as impressive in 3A conference play, going unbeaten against league opponents. Their defense has been absolutely dominant, and their ability to shut down opposing offenses has made them one of the most feared teams in the classification.
Eagle III finished 8-1 overall, but their undefeated conference performance has put everyone on notice.
Could we see both Eagle Academy programs celebrating championships this year?
It’s certainly possible, but the playoffs are a completely different animal.
From the Championship Game to Missing the Playoffs: What Happened in 3A?
This might be one of the most surprising storylines of the entire season.
Last year, Sheepshead Bay completed a historic undefeated championship season, defeating James Madison 46-6 in the 3A championship game.
Fast-forward to 2026, and both programs find themselves outside the postseason picture.
That’s a dramatic change for two teams that were playing for a championship just one year ago.
Sheepshead Bay showed flashes of its championship identity during the season, including a convincing 40-14 victory over James Madison in October. However, the Sharks were unable to replicate their historic 2025 campaign.
James Madison also entered the season with expectations after returning several players from its championship appearance, but the Golden Knights struggled to find consistency.
Another question surrounding this situation involves reported forfeited games associated with one of the programs.
What happened? Why were games forfeited, and how did those results affect the team’s postseason chances?
Those are questions that deserve a clear explanation before conclusions are drawn.
For two teams that represented the best of 3A just one season ago, this is an unexpected ending and a reminder of how quickly things can change in high school football.
William C. Bryant Was Almost Perfect — Until Boys & Girls Had Something to Say
For most of the 2026 season, William C. Bryant looked nearly unstoppable in the 2A division.
The Owls entered their final regular-season matchup undefeated, having already collected impressive victories over several quality opponents, including Transit Tech.
But Boys & Girls had other plans.
In one of the most interesting results of the final weekend, Boys & Girls defeated Bryant 36-28, handing the Owls their first loss of the season.
That victory was a huge statement from the Kangaroos and a reminder that records don’t always tell the complete story.
For Bryant, the question now becomes how the team responds to adversity. Losing your final regular-season game isn’t ideal, but it can also serve as a wake-up call.
For Boys & Girls, the victory showed that they have the ability to compete with some of the best teams in their classification.
Could this late-season result be a sign of things to come?
Tottenville Deserves More Respect
Let’s talk about Tottenville.
The Pirates finished 6-4 overall, but that record doesn’t tell the full story of their season.
Tottenville challenged itself against quality competition and continued to show why it remains one of the toughest programs in the PSAL.
One of the more impressive things about the Pirates was their ability to remain competitive in difficult matchups. Their narrow 14-12 loss against Erasmus Hall showed just how close they are to the defending 4A champions.
They also responded with important victories, including a win over Abraham Lincoln and a strong finish against Staten Island rival Curtis.
Tottenville has proven that it can play physical football, compete with talented programs, and make adjustments.
While Eagle Academy II might be receiving most of the attention, nobody should overlook Tottenville.
This is a team capable of making some noise when the postseason begins.
Curtis High School: Did the Warriors Underachieve?
Coming into the 2026 season, Curtis was one of the most talked-about programs in the city.
With the firepower the Warriors acquired during the offseason and the talent already within the program, expectations were extremely high.
Many believed Curtis had the pieces to make a serious championship run.
And while finishing 7-3 is certainly not a terrible season, it is fair to ask whether this team lived up to those expectations.
Curtis started strong, winning its first six games before suffering a 41-26 loss to Abraham Lincoln. The Warriors responded with an impressive 38-6 victory over JFK, but losses against other strong opponents raised questions about consistency.
For a team with championship aspirations, simply having talent isn’t enough.
Can the Warriors put together four complete quarters against the best teams in the city? Can they eliminate mistakes and execute in the biggest moments?
Curtis has shown flashes of being a dangerous football team. The question is whether those flashes can turn into a championship-level performance.
Erasmus Hall: Never Count Out the Dutchmen
At some point, we have to stop questioning Erasmus Hall.
The defending 4A champions opened the season with difficult out-of-state competition, but once league play began, the Dutchmen reminded everyone why they remain one of New York City’s premier football programs.
Erasmus finished 7-3 overall and closed the regular season on a six-game winning streak.
Their victories over Tottenville and other quality opponents demonstrated that this group remains a serious threat.
The Dutchmen have the coaching, championship experience, and culture that many programs are still trying to establish.
Eagle Academy II may have the undefeated record, but Erasmus Hall has the championship pedigree.
If these two programs eventually meet with a championship on the line, it could be one of the most anticipated matchups of the season.
South Shore: A Young Team With a Bright Future
Not every successful season can be measured strictly by wins and losses.
South Shore went through its share of growing pains in 2026, but there is plenty of reason for optimism heading into next season.
The Vikings featured a young roster that was forced to learn and develop while competing in one of the toughest divisions in New York City.
There were difficult losses, but also valuable experience gained against established programs.
Their narrow 24-20 loss against JFK to close the season showed that they can compete.
The question heading into 2027 is simple: How much of that young core returns?
If South Shore can retain its talent, continue developing its players, and build consistency on both sides of the football, the Vikings could be one of the more improved teams in the PSAL next season.
Don’t be surprised if South Shore becomes a much more difficult opponent in 2027.
Other Programs That Deserve Attention
A. Philip Randolph: The Cougars have been one of the strongest programs in 3A and continue to establish themselves as legitimate championship contenders. Their physical style of football and ability to produce victories make them a program that nobody should take lightly.
New Utrecht: The Utes quietly put together an impressive season. With six victories in seven reported games, New Utrecht has shown that it belongs in the conversation among 3A’s stronger teams. Can they make a deep postseason run?
Stuyvesant: Don’t overlook the Peglegs. An 8-2 record and an explosive offense have helped Stuyvesant establish itself as a serious team in 3A. This is a program capable of putting points on the scoreboard and creating problems for opposing defenses.
Abraham Lincoln: The Railsplitters had an inconsistent season, but their victory over Curtis showed what this team is capable of when everything comes together. The biggest challenge has been producing that same level of football week after week.
JFK Campus: The Knights put together a strong season and deserve recognition for remaining competitive in 4A. Their ability to win difficult matchups has made them an interesting team to watch.
Transit Tech and McKee/Staten Island Tech: Both programs have put together impressive records in 2A. While much of the attention has been focused on Bryant, these teams have made strong cases of their own.
August Martin: One of the stories worth talking about in the lower classifications. An undefeated 8-0 record deserves attention regardless of division. The challenge now is finishing the job.
Beacon and Mott Haven: Both programs have quietly put together successful seasons and deserve recognition for their consistency. The PSAL is much bigger than just the 4A and 3A divisions, and these teams are proving that quality football is being played across the city.
The Bigger Picture: The Playoffs Will Tell Us Everything
The 2026 PSAL regular season gave us just about everything we could ask for.
We saw undefeated teams dominate. We watched talented programs fall short of expectations. We witnessed late-season upsets and saw young teams begin building toward the future.
But now the regular season is over.
The records, rankings, preseason predictions, and social media conversations can only take teams so far.
Eagle Academy II has been dominant, but can the Eagles finish the job?
Eagle Academy III has controlled 3A conference play, but can they bring home a championship?
Will Erasmus Hall continue its championship tradition? Can Tottenville make another run? Will Curtis finally put everything together?
And who will emerge from the lower classifications?
One thing is certain: The 2026 PSAL season has given us plenty to talk about, but the biggest stories are still waiting to be written.
At After the Snap Network, we’ll be watching closely as the road to the championship continues.