NY Metro High School Football
My ATS
Home Page

CHSFL Monday Morning Wrap Up: Stepinac Bounces Back, Hayes Wins a Thriller

Week 2 brought another round of non-league tests for the CHSFL, and a few teams responded exactly the way they needed to.

Archbishop Stepinac bounced back in a big way, Cardinal Hayes survived a thriller against Middletown, and several of the league’s top programs continued testing themselves against New Jersey competition.

Archbishop Stepinac 38, Immaculata 16

Stepinac needed a response after last week’s 62-24 loss to CBA Albany. The Crusaders got one. Stepinac handled Immaculata 38-16, improving to 2-1 and putting together a much cleaner performance on both sides of the ball. The win was especially important because Immaculata had just scored 50 points the week before against St. Joseph-by-the-Sea.

That makes this one of the better bounce-back performances of the weekend.

Cardinal Hayes 30, Middletown 28

Hayes picked up its first win of the season in dramatic fashion, holding off Middletown 30-28 at Columbia University. The Cardinals entered the game looking to rebound from a six-point loss to Pope John, and they found a way to close out a tight one against the defending Delaware state champion. Middletown entered the season after a 10-3 campaign and a state title in 2025.

For Hayes, this was less about style points and more about finishing.

Battle of the Bridge continues

The rest of the weekend featured another heavy New York–New Jersey slate, with Iona Prep hosting Paramus Catholic, Monsignor Farrell facing DePaul Catholic, Chaminade hosting Seton Hall Prep and St. Anthony’s taking on St. Peter’s Prep.

Those matchups were part of the expanded Battle of the Bridge weekend, which has grown from the original three-game concept into a much larger early-season measuring stick between the two states.

Around the CHSFL

Kellenberg also stepped outside the league again, facing South Shore after splitting its first two games against Chaminade and New Rochelle. The Firebirds remain one of the more interesting teams in the league after opening with a win over Chaminade and then losing by just two points to New Rochelle.

Players Who Made Noise

Nahum Pierre, Archbishop Stepinac — Pierre continues to be one of the most important pieces in the Stepinac offense, and the Crusaders’ 38-point response against Immaculata was exactly what they needed after last week.

Hayes’ late-game playmakers — In a two-point win over Middletown, the Cardinals made enough plays down the stretch to finish a game that could easily have gone the other way. Kymonni Valentine and Ethan Waife made key plays  on offense and defense respectively to jumpstart the Hayes comeback. 

The Big Picture

Stepinac got back on track. Hayes found a way to win a close one. And the CHSFL’s top programs continue to challenge themselves against quality non-league competition before league play takes over the schedule. That is what these early weeks are supposed to do: expose weaknesses, test depth and give teams a chance to figure out who they are before October.

ATS NETWORK — NY FOOTBALL LIVES HERE